Emergency physician's perception of cultural and linguistic barriers in immigrant care: results of a multiple-choice questionnaire in a large Italian urban emergency department

doi:10.5847/wjem.j.1920-8642.2015.02.005

Abstract

Abstract:

BACKGROUND: A poor communication with immigrants can lead to inappropriate use of healthcare services, greater risk of misdiagnosis, and lower compliance with treatment. As precise information about communication between emergency physicians (EPs) and immigrants is lacking, we analyzed difficulties in communicating with immigrants in the emergency department (ED) and their possible associations with demographic data, geographical origin and clinical characteristics.
METHODS: In an ED with approximately 85 000 visits per year, a multiple-choice questionnaire was given to the EPs 4 months after discharge of each immigrant in 2011.
RESULTS: Linguistic comprehension was optimal or partial in the majority of patients. Significant barriers were noted in nearly one fourth of patients, for only half of them compatriots who were able to translate. Linguistic barriers were mainly found in older and sicker patients; they were also frequently seen in patients coming from western Africa and southern Europe. Non-linguistic barriers were perceived by EPs in a minority of patients, more frequently in the elderly and frequent attenders. Factors independently associated with a poor final comprehension led to linguistic barriers, non-linguistic obstacles, the absence of intermediaries, and the presence of patient's fear and hostility. The latter probably is a consequence, not the cause, of a poor comprehension.
CONCLUSION: Linguistic and non-linguistic barriers, although quite infrequent, are the main factors that compromise communication with immigrants in the ED, with negative effects especially on elderly and more seriously ill patients as well as on physician satisfaction and appropriateness in using services.

Key words: Linguistic barriers, Cultural barriers, Immigrants, Emergency department

Filippo Numeroso, Mario Benatti, Caterina Pizzigoni, Elisabetta Sartori, Giuseppe Lippi, Gianfranco Cervellin. Emergency physician's perception of cultural and linguistic barriers in immigrant care: results of a multiple-choice questionnaire in a large Italian urban emergency department[J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2015, 6(2): 111-117.

Figures/Tables 5

Figure 1.

Table 1

Table 2

Table 3

Table 4

References 32

1	United Nations. International migration and development. Report of the Secretary- General United Nations, 2006.
2	Istituto Nazionale di Statistica. Rapporto annuale 2012. La situazione del paese. Available from: http://www.istat.it/it/files/2012/05/Rapporto-annuale-2012.pdf(in italian).
3	Norredam M, Nielsen SS, Krasnik A. Migrant's utilization of somatic healthcare services in Europe-a systematic review. Europ J Pub Health 2010; 20:555-563.
4	Norredam M, Krasnik A, Sorensen TM, Keiding N, Joost Michaelsen J, Sonne Nielsen A. Emergency room utilization in Copenhagen: a comparison of immigrant groups and Danish-born residents. Scand J Public Health 2004; 32:53-59.
5	Buron A, Cots F, Garcia O, Vall O, Castells X. Hospital emergency department utilisation rates among the immigrant population in Barcelona, Spain. BMC Health Serv Res 2008; 8:51-60. pmid: 18315871
6	Rué M, Cabré X, Soler-González J, Bosch A, Almirall M, Serna MC. Emergency hospital services utilization in Lleida (Spain): A cross-sectional study of immigrant and Spanish-born populations BMC Health Services Research 2008; 8:81-89. pmid: 18402704
7	Davidovitch N, Filc D, Novack L, Balicer RD. Immigrating to a universal health care system: utilization of hospital services by immigrants in Israel. Health Place 2013; 20:13-18. doi: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2012.11.005 pmid: 23291060
8	Sandvik H, Hunskaar S, Diaz E. Immigrants' use of emergency primary health care in Norway: a registry-based observational study. BMC Health Services Research 2012; 12:308-319.
9	De Luca G, Ponzo M, Rodríguez Andrés A. Health care utilization by immigrants in Italy. Int J Health Care Finance Econ 2013; 13:1-31. pmid: 23239018
10	Zinelli M, Musetti V, Comelli I, Lippi G, Cervellin G. Emergency Department utilization rates and modalities among immigrant population. A 5-years survey in a large Italian urban Emergency Department. Emergency Care Journal 2014; 10:22-25.
11	Regione Emilia Romagna, Agenzia Sanitaria e Sociale Regionale. "La salute della popolazione immigrata in Emilia Romagna" Dossier 217-2011, ISSN 1591-223X. Available from: http://assr.regione.emilia-romagna.it/it/servizi/pubblicazioni/dossier/doss217(in italian).
12	Cooper LA, Roter DL, Johnson RL, Ford DE, Steinwachs DM, Powe NR. Patient-centered communication, ratings of care, and concordance of patient and physician race. Ann Intern Med 2003; 139:907-915. pmid: 14644893
13	Harmsen H, Bernsen R, Meeuwesen L, Thomas S, Dorrenboom G, Pinto D, et al. The effect of educational intervention on intercultural communication: results of a randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2005; 55:343-350. pmid: 15904552
14	van Wieringen JC, Harmsen JA, Bruijnzeels MA. Intercultural communication in general practice. Eur J Public Health 2002; 12:63-68. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/12.1.63 pmid: 11968523
15	Flores G. The impact of medical interpreter services on the quality of health care: A systematic review. Med Care Res Rev 2005; 62:255-299. pmid: 15894705
16	Lillie-Blanton M, Laveist T. Race/ethnicity, the social environment, and health. Soc Sci Med 1996; 43:83-91. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(95)00337-1 pmid: 8816013
17	van Ryn M, Burke J. The effect of patient race and socio-economic status on physicians' perception of patients. Soc Sci Med 2000; 50:813-828. doi: 10.1016/s0277-9536(99)00338-x pmid: 10695979
18	Ferguson WJ, Candib LM. Culture, language, and the doctor-patient relationship. Fam Med 2002; 34:353-361. pmid: 12038717
19	Ramirez AG. Consumer-provider communication research with special populations. Patient Educ Couns 2003; 50:51-54. doi: 10.1016/s0738-3991(03)00080-6 pmid: 12767585
20	Kiesler DL, Auerbach SM. Integrating measurement of control and affiliation in studies on physician-patient interaction: The interpersonal circumplex. Soc Sci Med 2003; 57:1707-1722. pmid: 12948579
21	Saha S, Arbelaez JJ, Cooper LA. Patient-physician relationships and racial disparities in the quality of health care. Am J Public Health 2003; 93:1713-1719. doi: 10.2105/ajph.93.10.1713 pmid: 14534227
22	van Ryn M, Fu SS. Paved with good intentions: Do public health and human service providers contribute to racial/ethnic disparities in health? Am J Public Health 2003; 93:248-255. doi: 10.2105/ajph.93.2.248 pmid: 12554578
23	Nierkens V, Krumeich A, de Ridder R, van Dongen M. The future of intercultural mediation in Belgium. Patient Educ Couns 2002; 46:253-259. pmid: 11932124
24	Kleinman MA. Patients and healers in the context of culture. London: University of California Press; 1980.
25	Ramirez D, Engel KG, Tang TS. Language interpreter utilization in the emergency department setting: a clinical review. J Health Care Poor Underserved 2008; 19:352-362. doi: 10.1353/hpu.0.0019 pmid: 18469408
26	Official Journal of Italian Republic, n. 76, 31/03/2008:68-74.
27	United Nations Statistics Division "Composition of macro geographical (continental) regions, geographical sub-regions, and selected economic and other groupings" Available from: http://millenniumindicators.un.org/unsd/methods/m49/m49regin.htm.
28	Mahmoud I, Hou XY, Chu K, Clark M. Language affects length of stay in emergency departments in Queensland public hospitals. World J Emerg Med 2013; 4:5-9. pmid: 25215085
29	Mahmoud I, Hou XY, Chu K, Clark M. Language and utilisation of emergency care in Queensland. Emerg Med Australas 2013; 25:40-45.
30	"Emergency room and immigrants: good practices" An extract from the database of good practices in humanization of Cittadinanza attiva and the Tribunal for Patients' Right from the "Andrea Alesini Prize, 2010". Available from: http://www.scribd.com/doc/47860447/Pronto-soccorso-e-cittadini-migranti-le-buone-pratiche(in Italian).
31	Padela AI, Punekar IR. Emergency medical practice: advancing cultural competence and reducing health care disparities. Acad Emerg Med 2009; 16:69-75.
32	Beach MC, Price EG, Gary TL, Robinson KA, Gozu A, Palacio A, et al. Cultural competence: a systematic review of health care provider educational interventions. Med Care 2005; 43:356-373. pmid: 15778639

Variables	Results
Gender (n, %)
Males	248 (51.8)
Females	231 (48.2)
Mean age (years)	38 (18-85)
Geographical origin (%)
North Africa	23.9
Eastern Europe	22.0
West Africa	17.8
Southern Europe	14.7
Other	21.6
Priority color code (%)
White	14.3
Green	71.0
Yellow	13.1
Red	1.7
ED use^a (%)
Occasional	82.6
Habitual	12.7
Frequent attainder	4.8

Variables	%
Linguistic barriers
None	43.4
Mild	32.0
Substantial	14.1
Complete	10.6
Intermediaries
Able to translate	24.9
Not able to translate	6.4
No intermediaries	68.3
External translators	0.4
Final level of comprehension
Full	58.1
Partial	29.5
Low	11.8
None	0.6
Physician's final satisfaction
Good	23.0
Neutral	68.0
Poor	9.0
Presence of
Patient fear, hostility, aggressiveness	8.4
Non-linguistic barriers	14.1
External influences	12.2

Variables	Significant linguistic barriers^a	Intermediares able to translate	Age >60 years	Non- linguistic barriers	Priority codes yellow or red	Patient's fear or hostility	External influences	Very poor or null final comprehension	Frequent ED use	EPs aversion
General population	24.8	25	7.2	14.1	14.6	8.4	12.2	12.4	18	9.0
Patients with very poor or null final comprehension	83.3^**	25.3^*	11.6	36.6^**	25.4^*	16.6^**	23^**	NA	21.1^*	34.3^**
Patients over 60 years old	58.3^**	63.9^**	NA	22.2	33.3^**	8.3	8.3	19.4	11.1	2.8
Patients with yellow or red code	43.8^**	32.9	16.4^**	20.5	NA	12.3	17.8	23.3^*	28.7^*	19.2^**
Habitual or frequent ED users	20	15.5	4.7	39^**	23.3^*	14.4	43.5^**	16.6^**	NA	19^**
Patients with a poor EPs final satisfaction	53.4^**	23.9*	2.3	37.2^**	30.4^**	27.9^**	30.2^**	46.5^**	37**	NA

Independent variables	B	Standard error	Beta	t	P value
Constant	-0.61	0.21	0.00	-2.85	0.00
Linguistic barriers	0.48	0.03	0.66	16.95	0.00
Absence of intermediaries	0.19	0.03	0.22	5.88	0.00
Non-linguistic barriers	0.45	0.07	0.22	6.44	0.00
Patient's fear or hostility	0.35	0.09	0.13	3.98	0.00
Geographical origin	-0.01	0.00	-0.06	-1.85	0.07
Age (recodified in groups)	-0.18	0.10	-0.06	-1.81	0.07
Frequency of ED use	0.07	0.05	0.05	1.49	0.14
Priority code	0.03	0.04	0.02	0.06	0.55
Gender	0.01	0.05	0.01	0.16	0.87

[1]	Weiming Wu, Min Li, Huilin Jiang, Min Sun, Yongcheng Zhu, Gongxu Zhu, Yanling Li, Yunmei Li, Junrong Mo, Xiaohui Chen, Haifeng Mao. Development of an emergency department length-of-stay prediction model based on machine learning [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2025, 16(3): 220-224.
[2]	Jingyuan Xie, Jiandong Gao, Mutian Yang, Ting Zhang, Yecheng Liu, Yutong Chen, Zetong Liu, Qimin Mei, Zhimao Li, Huadong Zhu, Ji Wu. Prediction of sepsis within 24 hours at the triage stage in emergency departments using machine learning [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2024, 15(5): 379-385.
[3]	Payush Chatta, Brian Diep, Jakrin Kewcharoen, Daniel Rossie, Cory Toomasian, Purvi Parwani, Dmitry Abramov. The diagnostic yield for computed tomography pulmonary angiography in patients with anticoagulation [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2024, 15(4): 251-255.
[4]	Jie Er Janice Soo, Yuan Helen Zhang, Gek Hsiang Lim, Fatimah Lateef. Bicycle-related traumatic injuries: a retrospective study during COVID-19 pandemic [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2024, 15(4): 256-262.
[5]	Rex Pui Kin Lam, Zonglin Dai, Eric Ho Yin Lau, Carrie Yuen Ting Ip, Ho Ching Chan, Lingyun Zhao, Tat Chi Tsang, Matthew Sik Hon Tsui, Timothy Hudson Rainer. Comparing 11 early warning scores and three shock indices in early sepsis prediction in the emergency department [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2024, 15(4): 273-282.
[6]	Jonathan Chabon, Jemer Garrido, Deanna Schreiber-Gregory, Jefferson Drapkin, Sergey Motov. Trends in oxycodone and oxycodone-containing analgesics administration for back pain in emergency departments in the USA (2007-2018) [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2024, 15(3): 169-174.
[7]	Yedalm Yoo, Shin Ahn, Bora Chae, Won Young Kim. Performance of the EDACS-ADP incorporating high-sensitivity troponin assay: Do components of major adverse cardiac events matter? [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2024, 15(3): 175-180.
[8]	Diogo de Almeida Fernandes, Guilherme de Freitas Camões, Diana Ferreira, Carolina Queijo, Carlos Fontes-Ribeiro, Lino Gonçalves, Rui Pina, Natália António. Prevalence and risk factors for acquired long QT syndrome in the emergency department: a retrospective observational study [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2023, 14(6): 454-461.
[9]	Fady Y. Hijji, Andrew D. Schneider, Matthew D. Thomas, Joseph G. Lyons, Daniel D. Bohl, Jennifer L. Jerele, Michael J. Prayson. Knowledge of radiation exposure associated with common trauma imaging modalities among orthopaedic surgeons, emergency medicine physicians, and general surgeons in the United States [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2023, 14(4): 294-301.
[10]	Xinlei Wang, Yao Sun, Xiaoyu Ni, Shu Zhang. Development and validation of an emergency bloodstream infection score for predicting in-hospital mortality in patients with community-acquired bloodstream infections [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2023, 14(4): 280-286.
[11]	Ahmed Faidh Ramzee, Ayman El-Menyar, Mohammad Asim, Ahad Kanbar, Khalid Ahmed, Bahaa Daoud, Saji Mathradikkal, Ahmad Kloub, Hassan Al-Thani, Sandro Rizoli. The impact of emergency department length of stay on the outcomes of trauma patients requiring hospitalization: a retrospective observational study [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2023, 14(2): 96-105.
[12]	Jee Yen Kuck, Abdul Muhaimin Noor Azhar, Neena Wee, Rishya Manikam. Diagnostic accuracy of the tongue blade test combined with clinical signs to detect maxillary and mandibular fractures in the emergency department [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2023, 14(2): 122-127.
[13]	Guang-mei Wang, Yong Li, Shuo Wu, Wen Zheng, Jing-jing Ma, Feng Xu, Jia-qi Zheng, He Zhang, Jia-li Wang, Yu-guo Chen. The combination of creatine kinase-myocardial band isoenzyme and point-of-care cardiac troponin/ contemporary cardiac troponin for the early diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2022, 13(3): 163-168.
[14]	Ittai Shichman, Or Shaked, Shai Factor, Ahuva Weiss-Meilik, Amal Khoury. Emergency department electric scooter injuries after the introduction of shared e-scooter services: A retrospective review of 3,331 cases [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2022, 13(1): 5-10.
[15]	Ralphe Bou Chebl, Nader El Souki, Mirabelle Geha, Imad Majzoub, Rima Kaddoura, Hady Zgheib. Two-point compression ultrasonography: Enough to rule out lower extremity deep venous thrombosis? [J]. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2021, 12(4): 268-273.